About Time Travelling
Paul J. Nahin American Institute of Physics p408 £?? Distributed in UK
by OUP; ISBN 0883189356
John Gribbin
TIME TRAVEL has become, if not respectable, then certainly fashionable
in some quarters of the physics world over the past decade or so. Much of the
blame can be laid at the door of the astronomer Carl Sagan, who was writing a
science fiction novel in the summer of 1985, and asked the relativist Kip
Thorne, of CalTech, to come up with some plausible sounding scientific
mumbo-jumbo to "explain" the literary device of a wormhole through
space which could enable his characters to travel between the stars.
Encouraged to look at the equations of the general theory of relativity in a
new light, Thorne and his colleagues first found that there is nothing in
those equations to prevent the existence of such wormholes, and then realised
that any tunnel through space is also, potentially, a tunnel through time.
The laws of physics do not forbid time travel.
This realisation had two consequences. When Sagan's novel, Contact,
appeared in 1986 it contained a passage that read like pure Sf hokum, but
which was (although few readers realised it at the time) a serious science
factual description of a spacetime wormhole. And as Thorne and his colleagues
began to publish scientific papers about time machines and time travel, the
spreading ripples have stimulated a cottage industry of similar studies.
Curiously, this anecdote does not feature in Paul Nahin's otherwise
remarkably comprehensive account of the fact and fiction of time travel.
Nahin is a professor of electrical engineering at the University of New
Hampshire, and the author of several published science fiction stories, some
dealing with the puzzles and paradoxes of time travel. He tells us how he
discovered, and "devoured" science fiction stories at the age of
ten, and this book is clearly a labour of love. The approach is scholarly,
with 36 pages of footnotes, nine technical (but not overly mathematical) appendices,
and a no-holds-barred bibliography. Nahin's style is distinctly more sober
than the material he deals with, but what he lacks in sparkle he certainly
makes up for in comprehensiveness.
The approach, in line with the author's background, is from the
fiction and towards the fact. Old favourites, such as H. G. Wells and Frank
Tipler, make their expected appearances, as do less familiar time travel
fictions from the nineteenth century (comfortably predating Albert Einstein's
theories) and more obscure scientists and philosophers. And, of course, the
familiar time travel paradoxes get a thorough airing.
There are, though, two major weaknesses in Nahin's treatment of the
science. The lesser is his discussion of black holes, which is weak and
sometimes a little confused. Much more importantly, though, he fails to
appreciate how the "many worlds" interpretation of quantum
mechanics allows a time traveller to go back in time and alter the past
without producing problems such as the notorious grandfather paradox. In the
conventional version of the paradox, a traveller goes back and murders his
grandfather as a young boy, so the traveller could never have been born, so
grandfather never died -- and so on. But in the many worlds version
(championed today by David Deutsch, of the University of Oxford), the act of
killing grandad creates a new reality, so that when the traveller then goes
forward in time he is no longer in his own world, but in the universe
"next door". This explains, for example, some of the more subtle
touches in the "Back to the Future" trilogy of movies, which Nahin
comments on while missing their point entirely. But although the book is
flawed, it is still welcome. It does not lend itself to being read from front
to back like a novel, but is ideal to dip in to and hop around in, like a
time traveller dipping in to history. It is also a first class reference book
for anyone interested in the Sf side of time travel, and one that will be
welcomed by the fans -- at least, they will welcome it when and if it becomes
available in paperback at a sensible price.
|
|

No comments:
Post a Comment